1. Choose four or five job-related criteria
Use the actual brief: service judgement, task accuracy, team coordination or supervisory experience. Define what a useful answer would demonstrate for each. Avoid vague criteria such as “culture fit” without a job-related explanation.
2. Ask for a specific example
Try: “Tell me about a busy shift when priorities changed. What did you do first, and why?” Follow up on the person’s own actions and what happened. Give each candidate a comparable opportunity to explain their experience.
3. Record evidence before giving a score
“Described how they reassigned two tasks and checked handover” is more useful than “confident”. Use a small scale with clear definitions: limited evidence, meets requirement or strong evidence. A missing example is a question to explore, not a reason to guess.
4. Explain the work and invite questions
An interview is also the candidate’s chance to assess the role. Cover working arrangements, expectations, reporting line and next steps. Ask what information they still need to decide whether the role is suitable.
5. Debrief while the detail is fresh
Ask interviewers to complete notes independently, then compare evidence together. Identify outstanding verification before an offer decision. Keep records securely and share them only with people involved in hiring.
This guide offers general preparation ideas. Check hiring decisions and legal or regulatory requirements against your specific circumstances.
